|
Post by Rob W on Apr 11, 2016 20:31:35 GMT
2 Votes
|
|
|
Post by colinallcars on Apr 11, 2016 22:04:35 GMT
Stephen Clarke Started drinking again. I like the simplicity of this song and the arrangement. Lovely authentic sound, like The Quarrymen circa 1962. Sounds like a live band - raw and energetic and truthful.
Rob Warner Coffee (any time at all) Love the drumming on this, especially the bit after ‘anytime at all’. Great harmonies and a simple and effective guitar solo too.
Tim and Julie Definitely blank page Really love the guitar work on this one. For some reason it reminded me of Turning Japanese, which is one of my favourite songs of all time. Vocal reminded me of Bowie circa mid seventies. Very nice.
Christian Duffin My drink free world Now this starts off like it should have been an offering from Prog-rock month - touch of the Wakemans or Genesis? Great lyrics, as usual., a sentiment that I’m sure many people will identify with .The ‘in my drink free world’ hook is inspired, but I think the whole thing is just a bit too complicated for its own good.
Phil Sanderson Lager The nightmare of office parties, and boozed up colleagues looking for a fight and a curry. The extended guitar breaks just reminded me of days in the late 70s that I spent whirling around uncontrollably. Lager indeed!
|
|
|
Post by eddiecustard on Apr 11, 2016 22:48:14 GMT
The quality is high again, and it’s interesting that only Rob has written about an individual drink. The rest of us have focused largely on the negative consequences of drinking alcohol. Which reminds me - I could murder a pint.
Colin Parish – Pour Me Another One, Do
It’s all come together in fine style for Colin on his comeback. This is a poignant, atmospheric , classy tune - up there with I Am A Nurse as one of his finest creations so far.
Some lovely chord changes here. It’s a straight 4/4 but he drops instruments in and out cleverly to give it an interesting rhythmic feel.
The vocals are overpowered a little by the instruments in the verses – especially the first one – and I wonder if the sitar should be put on the subs’ bench now and again. But these are small gripes; the overall quality of the song is very high. I like the ironic/deluded tone of the narrative voice, highlighted in sections such as: ‘Every day was fine, every day was a laugh, falling on my face, falling on my arse.’
The ‘Pour Me Another One, Do’ line stands out imperiously; a fine melody, very well sung.
It’s an excellently constructed portrait of a drunk spiralling downwards – sad, with a tune that tugs on the heartstrings. I like the way it describes a week in this woman’s drinking life, involving thoughtful touches such as a soak in the bath, and a gym visit, culminating in the worrying prospect of a big blow-out at the weekend. Superb.
Stephen Clarke - Started Drinking Again
A masterwork hewn at the frontier by ‘Dark’ Clarke. Wondrous guitar intro: dirty, twanging, threatening, and full of the sort of echo and vibrato that achieves its aim; pulling us into a Wild West that we know will contain trouble.
The song exerts a grip that holds fast till the climax, where the guitar motif has been stripped decisively of accompanying instruments. (The interplay of the two guitars is very good throughout).
The repetitive aspect of the lyric works neatly in this sort of blues song because it helps emphasise the melancholia that can come with heavy drinking and a love lost.
Everything is spot on here - the drum work and its excellently judged prominence in the mix, the singing and harmonies, the excellent guitar solo on 1.03 that builds to the glorious bend at the finish, and – perhaps notably of all – the memorable, jagged guitar riff.
It’s reminiscent of your early classic Ain’t No Room, and even more compelling.
You’ve never sounded better.
Rob Warner – Coffee (Anytime At All)
Great to hear a hymn to coffee – I’m on decaff and I miss the hard stuff.
Rob’s work generally sounds more laid back and has more breathing space than most of our songs, and the same is the case here. The drums and bass are very tight and this gives him the foundation to layer the vocals and other instruments on a rock solid base.
‘You would be a latte: creamy, smooth and hot,’ is a great way of telling somebody you like them.
There’s a lovable breezy, pop/ funk feel , with all of Rob’s usual ingredients: excellent, enthusiastic signing and harmonising. The first part of verse one of just vocal and bass works really well, and is complemented neatly by the organ afterwards. The harmonies towards the second verse are really good. Another highlight is the harmonising guitar work from 2.40.
A joyful song that sticks out this month because of its bright instrumentation and uplifting sentiment.
Tim and Julie - Defiantly Blank Page
Having caged the beast who cornered the metal market in glorious style last month, Tim is showing his pop skills for this excellently crafted piece of work.
The lilting, descending chords of the refrain sound exuberant, and it’s to his credit that he sings different lyrics on this section each time it comes round. This section is particularly effective in a melodic sense on the first repeat, with the names of the authors.
There’s a terrific rhyme about trying to drown sorrows in gin but realising they have ‘learned to swim’, and I really like the bit that comes just before each verse, with the broken up drumming and the harmonising guitars. The tuneful guitar playing shines through and, as last month, it’s all very well constructed, sung and played, with a good mix.
Defiantly, or definitely, another one to add to T&J’s good run.
Phil Sanderson - Lager
Phil paints a frightening and very vivid picture of a British night out in the company of young drinkers. At least it’s the ‘annual’ office trip and things may not be quite as apocalyptic on an average night.
His skill in lyric writing shines through to sum up the horror: ‘drinking lager makes you try harder, gives you strength to get what you’re after’, and in the bit about drinkers being ‘missed in trains and pissed in cars’. (At least I think those were the words.)
The chorus about 10, 20, 100 pints of lager (and a curry after)made me laugh, but I was reaching for Andrew’s Liver Salts when the count escalated to 30, 40, and then a million. After all that lot I think I’d have to skip the onion bhajis if I was going to tuck away a vindaloo.
The opening bass riff is great (reminiscent of Love is a Battlefield by Pat Benatar), but in places it’s out of time with the drums, most noticeably from 0:7 to 0:25.
I like the way Phil’s held back on the instrumentation, which brings the singing and drumming to the forefront. His trademark guitar work is as effective as ever in creating a threatening mood and carrying the tune, especially when the singing stops. I especially like the guitar part on the chorus and the way it follows the vocal line.
It wouldn’t quite be Phil if it wasn’t full of anguish, but the production is exemplary. There’s a tight arrangement, and it succeeds in describing the nature of a dispiriting spectacle.
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Apr 13, 2016 15:33:46 GMT
Pour Me Another One, Do - Colin Parish A really dreamy feel give us a false sense of serenity that hides the grim realisation that we’re hearing about a life lived dominated by alcohol. Just as I would imagine a problem drinker would do, you list all the problems and finish it off with ‘pour me another one, do.’ It’s a very interesting subject for a song and could serve as a warning of the banality of alcoholism. The lyrics could be clearer but, I do like the conversation type lyrics that mirror the sung lyrics. It reminds me of all the chatter in the pub. I really like the way the music builds gently to a resolution at ‘pour me another one.’ Thanks for the 'Turning Japanese' reference. I didn't get that when I did it but can certainly see it now. Like you, I really like that track.
Started Drinking Again - Stephen Clarke There is some nice guitar work during and after the solo. But, basically, it’s a blues shuffle in the ‘my baby done gone and left me’ style. Quite a departure from the normally crafted lyrics and story telling.
Coffee (Anytime at all) - Rob Warner It’s not rare that I smile at the, sometimes, contrived rhymes in your lyrics but the song is blinder. Some more showing off on the guitar but, I’m not sure you take it quite far enough. In my opinion, the guitar should have been used instead of the electric piano for the rhythm part (says a guitar player. Pinch of salt needed). It’s just that I think your voice dominates the piano and would be complemented by a slightly spiky guitar. This is all a bit nit-picky and more to do with the production. It’s just a good song.
Defiantly Blank Page - Me and Julie Guitars are a bit loud, drums a bit quiet (says the guitar player!). Could have done with a proper chorus instead of, or as well as, the guitar riff bit.
My Drink-Free World - Christian Duffin Wow, wow and again, wow! This is great. Since the departure of the custard drummer the creativity seems to have gone off the chart. I suppose the acid test of any song is: would I buy it? Yes! Yes I would, and, on the strength of this, I would probably buy the back-catalogue too. I love the unusual mix of instruments and that they all seem to be playing a ‘proper’ part (not just strumming chords or blanket keyboards). The backing vocals are superb. It makes me wonder if I put enough thought in before I gave up drink.
Lager - Phil Sanderson This is sort of Arctic Monkeys/Genesis cross over (Steve Hackett style guitar). It’s a bit of a caricature of Friday nights in many towns in the UK (if you believe the Daily Mail). It’s an interesting, and rich, area to write about, office politics and the dangers of an office party. I keep commenting on the guitar on your songs and this month is going to be no exception, I think there’s too much processing going on. I don’t mind heavy processing (big fan of The Police) but I’m not sure it’s a good fit for this song. Having said that, I really like the instrumental break.
|
|
|
Post by stephen on Apr 19, 2016 16:05:25 GMT
Colin P Pour me another one do Clever lyrics, with the irony really matching the mood of the music, especially in the chorus - "every day was fun" sounds positively Blur-like. I like the way a neat chord change lifts it to the "pour me another one do" line. Good hook. As you will probably have noticed, I'm into live instruments (and incapable of anything else). I just wonder whether some real electric guitar wouldn't add more weight and depth to the sound, and give it a real Blur-like bite. All you need is a bit of Graham Coxon.
Rob W Coffee any time at all I enjoyed this incursion into soul. Very neat opening riff, and as usual some great chord changes, especially that last one of the chorus. Great hook, and excellent vocals, very rhythmic. I like the way you build up the arrangement to maintain the energy of the song, and that tightly controlled guitar solo acts as a kind of second chorus. All-round excellently crafted song.
Tim and Julie W Definitely blank page Very nice stereo guitar effect, and not too loud, I don't think, because the guitars sit well either side of the vocals, especially because of the contrast between the controlled spoken voice and the distorting instruments. Plenty of riffs and licks to listen to, and I enjoyed the free and easy bass playing. The chords remind me of the Pretenders' "Stop your Sobbing", which is no bad thing.
Christian D My drink-free world You've got at least three hooks in there, and the instrumentation is brilliant, with non-stop attention to detail. The mixing is very subtle too, the way the banjo comes in to add some light plinking, then the distorted guitar takes us into a completely different feel, and the delicate piano arpeggios after the solo change it yet again. Excellent vocals, especially the layered oohs - Freddie Mercury would approve. Very clever lyrics too, right from the start, and the only thing I'd point out is that being "flat on my back throwing up" is a surefire way of choking on vomit that is very much your own. Your best song yet, I think, which is saying something.
Phil S Lager Excellent hook, and that "drinking lager" line is sort of Jam-like, as is the early threat of the office soaks heading "into town". Great vocals, all those different voices, and I enjoyed the humorous touches, especially the "curry after". The guitar solo at the end is very impressive, and even the slightly drunken bass playing works really well given the theme. The best thing is, though, that it's a new theme, new rhythm, lighter lyrics than usual, but very much your sound, your style. You just do your thing, which is what we should all be doing.
|
|
|
Post by philsanderson on Apr 21, 2016 22:08:53 GMT
Colin P – Pour me another one do I can only echo what Stephen commented re the wonderful irony and great lyrics. The sound you’ve created has, for me an apparent juxtaposition of menace and aching sadness. A great advert for the inherent dangers of overdoing alcohol.
Stephen C (and Marvin) – Started drinking again The tone of the music certainly fits the lyrics here. Love the interplay between the guitar parts – great use of echo/ reverb. There’s definitely a ‘live’ feeling to this – but at the same time I get various images in my head on each listening which suggest a video is in order for this one - sort of a wild west theme going on in my imagination.
Rob W- Coffee ( any time at all ) It’s a very assured and confidently delivered song. I suppose it’s partly or wholly due to your overwhelmingly positive feeling about Coffee. ( Dare I say addiction?? ) The line which includes ‘Fall’ ( American...) sounded a little incongruous with an English voice(?) I’ve come to expect a Rob style unexpected chord / key change at some point and you’ve delivered again! I’m especially impressed by both the sound and quality of the drum part throughout – I especially like it on verse 1 where it has extra ‘space’ in the mix
Tim and Julie W- Definitely blank page Quite a heady mix of retro styles from 70’s through to 90’s here.... I think Tim may take offence ( but obviously hope he doesn’t) if I say that this has more than a heavy element of Morrissey’s finest albums in the lyrical content, vocal tune and most particularly the twin guitar parts. I really like most of the aforementioned’s output, so I for one am very happy, even if my comments may ostracise me even further from the mainstream! Good separation of the two guitars throughout and well considered drum part.
Christian D - My drink-free world Another brilliant track selected from the latest Duffin million selling album! I especially like the opening sections and the later ‘break’ and verses without the electric guitar. I get a feeling I’m listening to this on a set in a saloon bar in a western with everything in sepia tones. Very evocative stuff! I wonder if you set out initially to leave drums off this one? It certainly works so well as it is – it’s just a thought on a compositional note and I am curious!
|
|
Karl
Junior Member
Posts: 72
|
Post by Karl on Apr 23, 2016 8:24:42 GMT
Sorry, but not enough time for a proper review of each song. I have enjoyed listening to the songs this month (mostly in the car), and 2 are stuck in my head, so they're the 2 I've voted for.
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on Apr 24, 2016 16:58:46 GMT
I too have listened without reviewing but I have voted. I will endeavour to get some words down soon but at least I made my votes count!!
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Apr 25, 2016 11:39:08 GMT
Well done Christian. A brilliant song.
I'm glad the Louis Theroux programmes wasn't on before we had to come up with drink-based songs.
Phil, you can liken me to Johnny Marr as often as you want. I'm just glad when I don't sound like me.
|
|
|
Post by eddiecustard on Apr 28, 2016 9:10:38 GMT
Thanks for the kind comments - much appreciated.
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on Apr 28, 2016 11:39:32 GMT
I'm proud to say I voted for the winner! A clear victory (though, not as clear as I'd have thought.) Well done (again) Christian. You're really getting the hang of this songwriting lark (sarcasm doesn't ever work for me in the written word. Me saying that to Christian is a bit like Lamahl complimenting Paul McCartney after he'd written 'Maybe I'm Amazed'!!)
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Apr 28, 2016 20:38:11 GMT
As Rob said: 'A clear victory (though, not as clear as I'd have thought.).'
Just a quick thought. There were 7 voters, one of them was Christian, who can't vote for himself, so the maximum score would be 6. That means two people didn't put 'drink free world' in their top two. I find that a surprise but, the voting has surprised me before and I expect it will again.
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on May 5, 2016 7:40:49 GMT
Late song review. Sorry
Colin P - Pour Me Another One, Do
This has the feel of a cross between Lindesfarne and Pink Floyd. I really, really enjoyed the instrumentation and a second and third listening had me laughing at some of the lyrics. It was very well observed, particularly ‘Thursday’s the start of the weekend’. Oh how true!
There were some really nice melodic touches particularly in the chorus and the ‘pour me another one, do’ line.
This is building nicely and I get a sense that the ‘Anthem’ month will be your finest moment.
Stephen C - Started Drinking Again
I read the blurb and had a fixed idea of how it would sound but this was pure Steeler’s Wheel’ for me and I could see this in a Quentin Tarantino film.
Blues songs seem so simple and yet there is a real art in this simplicity. I am a fan, as you know, and this does not disappoint the die-hard Stephen C fans. Fantastically put together and was the complete package - again!
Tim & Julie -
Increasingly assured, Tim & Julie once again produce a well thought out and beautifully mixed and produced hit. Whereas a lot of their early stuff could perhaps be described as ‘album tracks’, the latest batch has seen hit after hit and this song is not exception. What’s so impressive is the fantastic balance between the top quality aural experience and the well considered and executed lyrics. Loved it.
Christian D - My Drink Free World
If you start to listen to this and don’t get beyond 20 seconds there would be a danger that you’d think it was a Richard Stilgoe tribute (which isn’t really a criticism!) but this song is so much more than that. I think it’s very easy for one to take your brilliant arrangements, brilliant chord progressions and fantastic lyrics for granted but one has to sometimes take a step back and just listen and wonder. I’m completely in awe of this whole song. You are Torvill and Dean.
Phil S - Lager
The multi-layered vocals throughout give this a certain feel (is it the Mamas & Papas?) I really liked it. I loved the lyrics throughout and completely concur (as most people do, I’d imagine) with your blurb sentiment about the difference in drinking culture between the UK and Germany.
Instrumentally, I can only marvel at your ability to take a fairly normal song (for you) and ‘shred’ throughout.
This song should get a vote purely for the title let alone the song itself.
|
|