|
Post by Rob W on Feb 2, 2015 21:14:57 GMT
This is where we can comment and vote on 'Love' month! For the last time (and seeing as it was 'love' month) I have allowed multiple entries (oo-er.) From next month, second or third entries will go into another part of the website and a separate page will appear on the forum.
Hopefully, I will be able to add a Poll to this tomorrow, but if I am unable I may have to delete this one and create another so don't be too fast with your comments (but be pretty quick as I'm hoping to close it off at midnight on Valentine's Day.)
|
|
|
Post by stephen on Feb 4, 2015 14:34:36 GMT
Hi y'all Please don't listen to my effort yet - there's a tweaked version on its way. Rob kindly allowed this for purely artistic reasons. I'd used a pitifully awful drum track which (I think) totally spoilt the song, so today I sat down with a snare and a hi-hat and did some live drumming, which is still crap but at least it's live.
|
|
|
Post by eddiecustard on Feb 4, 2015 18:34:03 GMT
I thought last month it was hard to choose a top three, but it’s even more difficult this time. It seems that thinking about love has bought out the best in everyone.
Under Your Spell – Robbie Good Band
The opening here is really strong, with the band functioning superbly: guitar, organ, piano and bass locking together for a tight and confident minor blues swagger. I love the delivery of the line ‘I’m Under Your Spell’ and a brief snatch of what sounds like a backing vocal, but might have been a synth. It was such a good hook of a vocal line that I wanted it to come back. It never did, though; instead there was a succession of verses, and I couldn’t help thinking you’d have been close to a barnstormer if there had been a bit of a focal point for the song. That doesn’t detract from a fine vocal performance with some excellent vibrato, and some spot on musicianship. The mood is key here and on that count it’s a big success; the Claptonesque/smoky basement bar blues working to great effect. The guitar solo is very good, shifting from a low register to a high one with skill, with good use of space.
Valentine’s – Colin Parish
There’s a very nice bit of acoustic guitar and understated piano work at the beginning.
Lyrically it’s an interesting way of saying we’ve become so wrapped up in computers and phones that we don’t engage with each other enough. You’ve captured this well on: ‘Come out of your bedrooms and put away your phones/it’s time to face the real world if you’re not to be alone’.
That guitar solo sounds terrific and your harmony singing is as good as ever.
You’ve used stereo really effectively, with instruments popping in and out of the left and right speakers. There’s some really good interplay between the guitar and another synth sound towards the end. Well done.
Put it There My Son - Colin Parish
This has a lovely chorus and is a wonderful celebration of love. On top, it showcases once more your talents in juggling different instruments.
There’s an excellent intro with a group of synths sound and some very nice Spanish-style guitar and buzzy guitar. I like it that you’re not afraid to sing in a low register. It works well and shows the breadth of your vocal skills, given that some of your other stuff has been quite high. It’s certainly not ‘mawkish and embarrassing’ as you feared in your sleeve notes – it’s touching. The chorus is very good and it’s all clear and tuneful. ‘You’re in my heart and under my skin’ is a nice line and I like that bit where you say that your son will only appreciate your love for him at the time he has his own children. You’ve given a lesson in how to construct a song using a repeated four-chord sequence that sounds interesting all the way through because of the clever use of variations in the vocals and instruments. Excellent.
It Won't Be Long - Mike Gosling
You’re at the top of your game with this one. Very enjoyable for lots of reasons: beautifully played and sung, including good snare and cymbal work from Karl, a lilting tune and warm sentiments. It’s up there with Under Your Sky as a personal favourite of mine from your back catalogue.
All of the instruments are mixed and produced to a very high standard; best of all letting your velvety but strident vocals take centre stage.
Great that you used your Christmas present to kick things off – the ukulele sounds good. Then the accordion complements things well, and the bass comes in with perfect timing to provide further energy. That aah, aaah bit at the start of the bridge is brilliant.
It’s another reminder of your skills with words – there’s a directness and economy about the way the lyrics emerge, and the phrasing always fits very snugly around the instruments. I like the bit about the hearts melting the frost on the lawn, and ‘arms wrapped tight round our bodies warm and strong’. Lean, smart, tuneful and very enjoyable.
Valentine Moon – Colin Steward
Where the feck have you pulled this one from, Colin? After several months of inactivity I thought you may not be back but I’m very glad you are because this is wonderful. It’s such a gorgeous tune that it could have been handed to you through a crack in the clouds.
You’ve kept your piano playing fairly well hidden until now and I don’t know why – because it’s terrific. You play with finesse, verve and emotion. I will be phoning to book a lesson. The whole thing is etched with momentous chord sequences, and Robbie’s crooning is superb. He sings excellently throughout, especially the key line of ‘With you every night has a Valentine moon’, which is startlingly well delivered. I like the way that the vocal melody and piano melodies intertwine, sometimes with the same tune, following each quite closely now and again, and sometimes very different, but always complementary. The strings and drums are really good when the chorus kicks in.
I liked the longing in the line: ‘My hopes would always die when the postman passed me by’ and also the bits about the moon having a trance-like pull. There’s a funny (some would say endearingly daft) section of lyrics on the bridge where Christmas and birthdays are ‘overrated’ and ‘chocolate eggs and pancakes make you fat…away days and May Days… never turn out to be all that.’
The trumpet solo later on is great. You describe the song as ‘old fashioned’, but it feels timeless to me. It’s going to be hard for you to better this, but it’ll be intriguing to watch you try over the coming months. I hope you’ve played it to Sharon, but when she’s with you I don’t think you should perform it down your local boozer around other women. They will swoon.
Monumentally good.
(Don’t Forget My) Valentine - Patrick Duffin An excellent, light-hearted romp - nicely put together and arranged. There’s a playful and very effective accordion intro, with the trademark spot-on harmonies on the chorus. It has a hootenanny/hoe down feel and I like the lyric idea of your partner remembering global events to improve civil rights (and the Beatles playing in Saville Row) from the 60s but neglecting things closer to home. As you’d intended, these lyrics made me think of the slightly bizarre importance we put on cards (Christmas, birthdays etc) and that forgetting to send one can bring long term repercussions. The line ‘It’ll take me a year to forgive you my dear’ works really well. That slide guitar solo is inspired and the layered harmonies in the last chorus are a joy.
Love on the Doorstep – Tim and Julie Warner
Nice dreamy guitar and keyboard intro, and with a bassline that’s so great it looks like you’ve paid for a session guy. You’ve certainly achieved your ambition of creating a groove. This is a funky, sexy, sassy dance number. It reminds me of the Isley Brothers. I like that sudden blast of loud drums at 35 seconds too. This feels like a new direction for you into the dance world – and long may it continue. Despite all this (minor criticism alert) it feels like half a song. Short tunes are fine but after you established such a powerful and vibrant opening it seemed a shame to end things so quickly. I wanted to hear more of that bass and the jagged guitar. That said there are stacks of good things here, including the ‘stun gun smile’ line.
I Got a Crush on You - Stephen Clarke
A punk classic and one of your best. The chorus is excellent and I think it’s a sign of a good writer if a song sounds this impressive when it’s boiled down to the instrument on which you wrote it plus only a few extra bits. You said you worry that it needs drums. Maybe, but it’s very good as it is. STOP PRESS: you’ve just added some drums to the original version and they do give the song extra oomph. All this reminds me of your August song Waiting for a Drummer, although ironically that wasn’t even about drumming. (Rob – can I temporarily pull my song off the website to add some castanets?).
The Buzzcocks reference is evident, as you said, and I like the Jilted John elements. The harmonies on the bit just before the chorus work very well and then again in the chorus itself. That very brief section of lead guitar before the chorus is great.
As usual we don’t have to look far for some inspired lyrics. The bit about not being able to carry her school books because she doesn’t go to school is pure Buzzcocks, and I liked the lines: ‘How am I ever going to make you mine if I can’t even send you a valentine’ and ‘I’d offer to buy you roses…I am a bunch of neuroses when we meet eye to eye.’
Good work in adding the extra drums – sounds very punk now. I’d finished writing my review by the time I saw your note on the message board so I’ve added one or two lines rather than changing the whole thing.
Jilted John would be impressed. No morons in this band.
As Long as I Live – Phil Sanderson
Phil Sanderson and the Penguin Book of African Verse? That sounds like you and your new backing band, assembled with the riches generated from Symphony Two.
After laying waste to the field last month there’s a spring in your step and you’ve delivered another impressive tune. The vocals are improving all the time. Your songs bear the tastiest fruit after a few listens and this is the same. Much as I like your 12-string work I enjoyed the change of scenery provided by the classical guitar. It's very well played. That accordion bit on 1.40 is inventive and a clever surprise. Unlike most of the songs this month yours has quite a sad feel, and seems to be about a love lost. No matter – it’s another addition to your ‘Best of’ collection. That refrain of ‘so long when I call your name’ has stayed with me. Good stuff.
Valentine - Tim and Glyn
A great ballad, expertly played and sung. There’s a very nice opening – sparse and atmospheric with the two guitars and single vocal. There’s loads of space and that makes everything crystallise into something of beauty.
Glyn delivers some more high quality singing – and I think there’s one of the best lyrical sections about romantic love of the month: ‘I’ve known you over half my life/I’ve known you such a long time/ I don’t need a husband and you don’t want a wife/Please be my valentine. Another bit that works well is: ‘You’re the constant in this crazy life.’
It all sounds very economical in a sense, yet thoughtful, well planned and tuneful. Some of Tim’s guitar playing is a bit special. A definite winner.
Monkey See, Monkey Do - Tim and Julie Warner
More zoology from T and J, and I’m very glad to hear it. I’m going to stick my neck out and say this is even better than Rat Park. It feels like a companion piece to that song, with a related theme of controversial research involving animals poked and probed under cruel conditions. I love the theatrical vocals, the plinky-plonky organ and the moody guitar. The low pitched guitar playing round 1.20 is very expressive and the fact that you’ve written about something obscure from the 1930s is highly commendable.
I don’t always know who does what in your duo (apart from the vocal bits of course), but it doesn’t really matter. There are lyrical nuggets, and I like the clever psychoanalytical theorising of the very first line where you ponder whether the researcher was once a victim of the very problems he is now investigating among the monkeys in his lab: ‘If he’d been hugged more by his ma, would Harlow know he’d gone too far?’
In some hands the rhyming of rats, macaques, brats, and scats in rapid succession in the same verse would sound naff but you’ve pulled it off. Your stuff usually sits outside any conventional categories, though the spirit of Marc Ribot and The Fall live in this one. Like Love on the Doorstep it’s got a good dance groove - they’d have loved it at the Hacienda in the late 80s. Was I hearing things or did you lapse briefly into a cockney accent at one point?
That heavy breathing in the background sounds a bit scary on 2.00.
If we put 20 macaques in a room with an electronic organ would they eventually come up with this song? Possibly, but it would take a while because it’s very, very good.
|
|
|
Post by mikegosling on Feb 5, 2015 17:22:41 GMT
Apologies in advance for any duplication of comments (Eddie's review which I've just read has quite a few similarities to the notes I've just made - I'll try not to repeat too much!)
Robbie Good Band: An authentic slow burning blues. Good band sound (drums. bass, guitar, organ) and topped off with a vocal from Robbie which very much suits his voice (especially the nicely controlled vibrato). The bluesy sound for the guitar solo (a bit Stevie Ray Vaughan) is very appropriate. My main comment on the song is that I could have done with another section/middle 8. I was slightly thrown by the guitar solo coming in half way through the chord progression and then finishing halfway through the next repeat of the progression - but it works. Strongest part of the vocal for me is "Under Your Spell" and (repeat alert) I would have liked to hear it again later in the song. Good strong band song.
Colin P / Valentine: The instrumentation and slightly distant vocal give this a distinctly 60's feel to me. I like the "lonely people" start with its allusion to the Beatles. The repeated minor key chord progression felt a bit sombre for the message of the lyrics - maybe the music could have been a bit more up tempo. The lyrics and vocals are well done and the theme for the song was a very good idea.
Colin P / Put It There Son: This has a very nice groove / feel to it. The chorus hook "Put it there son" works well. There is a good string part accompanying the first chorus, which I would have liked to hear on the later chorus, but it does return at the end and the coda has a very good sound to it. I very much like the delivery of some lyrics especially the "under my skin" part where Colin sounds a little like Ray Davies to me.
Colin S: The Great American Songbook has been reopened and a previously undiscovered gem has been found. Valentine Moon is great. Each section is so well constructed. The piano playing and singing are definite highlights, but also the drums, bass, strings are all very well arranged and played. The muted trumpet is also excellent. lyric highlights for me are "Did it find you? Mesmerise you? Did it guide you to my heart?" and of course, the main chorus lyric of "With you each night has a Valentine moon" is classic. Great stuff.
Eddie C: A good intro and the guitar part for the verse is great. The chorus is really catchy and I really like the line "I want to see you once a day, at least". The chords for the chorus work really well - especially the last chord on "feast". The strings in the middle 8 are very good. And, of course, the "london" lyrics are terrific throughout. The music really complements the lyrics about visiting places in London and generally moving around London is echoed is the rhythmic feel to the song. The vocals/harmonies seemed to astray in the breakdown chorus, but otherwise, I really got onboard for this "moveable feast".
Patrick: I really like Cajun music and this song had a great feel to it. Apart from Clifton Chenier on accordion did I hear some washboard percussion as well. The lyric idea of contrasting the arcane knowledge some of us gather at the expense of the important personal stuff was very well executed. And a very good slide guitar solo to top it all off. There's not much Patrick can't do!
Tim and Julie/ Love on the doorstep: The drums and bass sound fantastic at the start of this - it does indeed have a great groove. The breakbeat for 2 bars is a bit of surprise but we expect this from Tim/Julie. The choice of vocal effect for the first verse is a neat complement to the lyric about asking Julie out on the phone. My favourite part of the vocal / lyric though is the pause before "dancing"! A strange song structure and not really a whole song for me but some really good bits in there.
Stephen Clarke: This song is laden with hooks. Although for me the production is still a bit underdone, the hooks more than make up for it. "If I could count the hours I've wasted" - great melody here. "All night/year long - dreaming only dreaming" - also a good hook here. The chorus "I gotta a crush on you" has a good vocal hook as well as that guitar / bass hook. Also, that bit of almost African sounding guitar before the chorus works very well. The rhyming of "roses" and "neuroses" is a highlight for me on the lyric front. I think, given the surfeit of hooks, I would have preferred the song to finish at about 2:20. I didn't think the middle 8 quite worked. The "Buzzcocks" is a good reference point for this song and when I bought their single "Oh S**t" i was disappointed that it only clocked in at 1:30. Seems about the right length now.
Phil S: A surprise from Phil in that this song has a conventional structure and breaks the 3 minute barrier. I enjoyed the simplicity of the lyric and thought that the use of strings underpinning the last chorus worked very well. The classical guitar worked well and the accordion was very well executed. A good effort from the symphonic king.
Tim and Glyn: This has a lovely guitar intro and that mood is maintained throughout. All the elements work very well: the acoustic guitar figure, bass, chorused electric guitars and of course a very micely judged vocal from Glyn. The highlight for me is definitely the section "don't need a husband, you don't need a wife, please be my Valentine" - this is excellent. The simple chorus sentiment of "Be my Valentine" is very well done. Excellent.
Tim and Julie/Monkey: A really good combination of instruments - the electric piano riff is especially good. The guitar sound does indeed remind me of Marc Ribot (an important element in those classic Tom Waits albums of the 80s). The lyrics are once again fab. The vocal delivery unique and works so well. The drop down for the final verse is well executed. A companion to Rat Park certainly, but may be more groovy and therefore easier to listen to? A success.
Absolutely no idea which songs to vote for - it is indeed getting harder each month to decide!
|
|
|
Post by patrickd on Feb 5, 2015 21:35:39 GMT
Patrick's thoughts - Once again well done everyone.
1 - Robbie Good - Under your spell. Lovely expansive rich sound, well mixed with lots of space in the middle for the heartfelt, quality vocal. The only thing missing for me is a chorus or some kind of repeated melodic riff to give it some structure. Nice to hear a band type production, reminded me of Black Magic Woman by Santana, or I put a spell on you by Screamin Jay.
2- Colin Parish - Valentines Echoes of Eleanor Rigby with the strings and "lonely people", meanders along nicely and develops wistfully. I like the lyrics "quit the dating websites", despite the uplifting theme, the music feels quite dark. Hints of Morrissey in there too.
3 - Put it there my son - Colin Parish Attractive melody to start, feels like a thematic development on from the previous. Again I like the contrasting mundane with the philosophical lyric. The drums bubble along nicely underneath giving it some stability. As with Robbie's I miss a chorus or repeated melodic riff to give it structure. Nice to hear the beginning section at the end to bookend it.
4 - It won't be long - Mike Gosling I get a sense of Mike having just written this, as it feels wintry and fresh, which is in the spirit of the thing. Like the sudden emergence of colour from the frost there's lots of melodic form fluttering around in the shape of Beatlesy Aaahs harmonies and accordions. Nice uplifting lyrical theme, and well done on using the ukulele and resisting the guitar, gives the tune more space. (By the way, the washboard in mine is actually a metal Zydeco Tie, a portable version of the Vest Frottoire, you wear it round your neck and play it with two supplied thimbles. twenty quid off ebay. Get one next christmas - bargain !)
5 - Valentine Moon - Colin Steward Marvelous, Cole Porteresque epic, I can imagine as a centrepiece to a Fred Astaire musical to end Act One, the audience transported as the scenery transforms behind the tuxedoed leading man. Beautifully realised with all the sharpened fifths, and florid piano. You could easily have gone overboard with this but you maintain the elegance till the end. It's pastiche but with a loving fondness for the source. I liked it a lot.
6 - Our Love is a moveable Feast - Eddie Custard Don't know whether Eddie considers late Jam period Weller to be an influence, but I hear a lot of that here. The upbeat and touching lyrics leap out of the shiny, insistent production, the a capella section is a good idea which builds nicely back into the chorus. Full of uplifting and poignant details, can love ever get better than a shared Baked Alaska at the Ivy ?
8 - Love on the Doorstep - Tim and Julie, I like the 70's funky style, lovely bass riff, with some effective Isley brother's lead guitar. I was getting into it, and would have liked it to develop into a full song.
9 - I've got a crush on you - Steve Clarke Funnily enough I listened to the Police's first album in the car today, and this reminds me of that. You've made a good job with the ingredients available, sparse guitar bits in unison with the bass underpin the chorus to good effect, and the pauses work really well. I can't believe I've not heard Coffee rhymed with Toffee before. It's got a bit of a flabby middle section, but then so have I.
10 - As long as I live - Phil Sanderson, It kind of sits between romantic and sinister, with reference to body parts. It's haunting in the way that Phil's tunes often are. I think it works well as a short rather menacing gothic piece, with the listener left entombed in the minor keys.
11 - Tim and Glynn Echoes of Tracy Chapman's Fast Car to start. Lovely to hear just the voice with the guitar, but it develops nicely when the band come in. Glad that it feels like it was written fresh for the task, understated and graceful, with an assured simplicity.
12 Tim and Julie - Monkey See, Monkey do It's got a cheeky infectious groove, which I like. Great Ribotesque guitar sound and solo. Great vocal in the style of nineties Tom Waits with his boneyard band. Two chords ? brave to leave it at that as I don't think it needs any more. Catchy chorus. Not sure I get a sense of Love or romance from it though. I can imagine a funny video like the marvellous basement Jaxx 'where's your head at' one.
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Feb 5, 2015 23:05:52 GMT
For a Valentine, or love, themed month I was expecting lots of stuff that would reference Barrys White and Manilow. Thankfully that expectation has not been realised. Some have battled with the restriction while others have embraced it.
I’ve just seen Patrick has posted and we seem to agree on quite a bit. Sorry for any duplication.
Under Your Spell - The Robbie Good Band As I am part of the Robbie Good band, I can’t really comment too much but, from the remarks so far, I would say it could have done with some kind of refrain. Maybe the instrumental break should have come a bit earlier in the song. It was deliberately done to have the instrumental break straddle two verses. I like ‘odd.’
Valentine - Colin Parish The strings are really good. I really like the sound of the guitar for the solo, and the question and answer section at the end between the acoustic guitar and piano is fantastic, that bit feels almost classical in the way it’s structured. It feels like you’re imploring lonely people to realise that they can do something about it, if they want to, and that ‘something’ is probably not spending more time indoors on dating websites. Not especially romantic, more like ‘get off your arse and find a life.’
Put There Son - Colin Parish More delightfully odd sounding guitar work at the start before the heavy riff comes in. Through the song the strings are offering subtle support for the guitar chords before they get a bit more involved as the song goes on. There’s nothing quite like being a parent but, when you’re a kid it’s all you have ever known and, can wonder why your parents get all soppy occasionally. A pretty concise run through the feelings that many parents go through.
It wont be long - Mike Gosling Great sound on the ukulele (no surprise, your sound is always great). Then the squeeze box and fiddle start up and it’s suddenly it feels like one of those promising days in spring. It’s a comfortable armchair ride of a song. I’ve tried but the lyrics keep passing me by on this, I just get distracted by the feel of it all.
Valentine moon - Colin Steward Wow, Colin! Just, wow! It could have come straight out of a Fred and Ginger musical. There’s just enough stuff going on to support the melody. It’s beautifully restrained playing under some great vocals.
Our Love is a moveable feast - Eddie Custard Great upbeat intro with the usual accomplished playing. It really pounds along and feels like it’s taking us somewhere. The lovely middle 8 give way to a nice eased off section with some nice guitar work, before the drop out section. I’m not sure, but I can’t quite satisfy myself the backing vocal for the drop out bit is quite right, while not being able to decide what it should be. Another strong song with great melodies and playing.
Don’t forget my valentine - Patrick Duffin This is superb. A really bouncy song with some great lyrics. With all those place names it sounds like a homage to Chuck Berry’s Route 66. More accordion to make it sound romantic. Love the way it pulls back for the Martin Luther verse and the the more obvious stops a little later. Slide guitar is a real winner. All the vocals are brilliantly done. Just a normal Patrick song, really.
Love on the door step - me and Julie Okay, NOW I can see it’s half a song but I was worried about it getting too repetitive (how long should you sustain a single idea?). In my mind the structure was like ‘sound and vision’ but I missed that by a mile.
I’ve got a crush on you - Colin Parish I liked the original version just fine. The lyrics are sharp and, if anything, I would say it needs fewer instruments. The song is good enough for you to do a Billy Brag job with it and just have voice and guitar. I was surprised how long it was because it didn’t feel like a long song. Having listened to both version (and having written that ‘less is more’), I’m not sure the drums are doing anything useful, instead of revelling in it’s own oddness, it’s trying to be a bit more conventional.
As long as I live - Phil Sanderson Well, it looks like you won’t need any help with classical guitar parts. Nice melody line with subtle support from some strings under the guitar is all good. I really like the accordion solo (they seem to be a popular choice for ‘love’ month). It sounds like a really heat-felt song that means you’re either a hopeless romantic or a stalker.
Valentine - Tim and Glyn Lovely simple figure to get us going that never gets swamped, thanks the restrained additions later on. Some of that stuff in the background reminds me of Robert Fripp. Superb. ‘Breaking hearts as they collide’ seems to stand out to me. Lovely simple refrain, very singable.
Monkey see, monkey do. If you are interested in looking up the original research upon which this song is based, be carful! It is truly disturbing.
|
|
|
Post by Colin Steward on Feb 6, 2015 14:02:45 GMT
I don’t know if anyone else is troubled with lyric writing as I am. Judging by these songs, probably not. I seem to spend forever trying to think of anything even remotely useable. Phil hinted at it in his sleeve notes but has a clever solution.
Under Your Spell - Robbie Good Band Like Tim, being part of this rules me out of commenting too much. I do agree with most, however, that it did need something else other than verse after verse. The way Rob realises the vocals never fails to impress me, I’m sure he could sing the dictionary and make it sound listenable. That would be the first time Aardvark was ever given a bluesy feel!
Valentine’s - Colin Parish I like this. Melancholy and a bit of a sad reflection of our modern times. The low piano in the minor key is very effective and well done, as are the guitar solos.
Put it There My Son - Colin Parish A very touching song. I feel like I’m invading a personal message sandwiched between the guitar solos. It’s not mawkish or embarrassing at all. I like the electronic drums just doing their thing, it doesn’t need any special tricks or acrobatics.
It Won’t Be Long - Mike Gosling A feel good song and good sounding uke playing. Karl’s percussion was just right with this. It builds very nicely and I felt swept along with it’s joyfulness. The repeating “Ah Ahs” is a pleasing little hook and very effective and I can imaging many people swaying and singing along with this. Nice crisp, clear recording too.
Our Love is a Moveable Feast - Eddie Custard I’m always envious of Eddie’s melodies - the way they weave around and are never too repetitive and so memorable. It’s fairly trademark now. It’s a really enjoyable song and I love the lyrics (“baked Alaska”) - very nicely done. Nice harmonies too. To me, there’s a bit of XTC in there. I always view your songs as a lesson in how to write a flowing, memorable melody.
(Don’t Forget My) Valentine - Patrick Duffin The only thing that stops this being full on Cajun is the fact that Patrick sings so much better than most authentic Cajun singers. I almost expected a full washboard break rather than the slide guitar but on reflection, a good choice. Great song, full of energy and engaging lyrics and so well delivered vocally. I really like the lyric about the Beatles roof top gig without ever having to use the word ‘Beatles’. Harmonies are just pure joy to listen to and sound brilliant with headphones. Clever twist about consequences of forgetting to send a card.
Love on the Doorstep - Tim & Julie Warner I heard a little of this in development and was struck how Jamiroquai and funky it sounded. I left me wanting more of the main body of the song (verses and choruses). As usual some fine guitar playing going on and interesting voicing in the chords.
I Got a Crush on You - Stephen Clarke I heard both versions of this and, I think Tim said, the extra drums really weren’t necessary. It stands up pretty well without them, not that they spoil it. It’s a kind of non-angry, non-political Billy Bragg!! It would work as a electric guitar punky song too so this is more like an unplugged version. Congratulations on rhyming roses with neuroses!
As Long As I Live - Phil Sanderson The trademark 12 strings gives way to the classical guitar and the effect is a much more reflective and subtle song than usual (apart from your winning entry last month). Nice little accordion break that was unexpected. And well done on getting under three minutes.
Valentine - Tim & Glyn Nice dreamy song that drifts along. Opening guitar is a really nice start and I like hearing the sounds of the fingers as they move over the strings. Good harmonies in the chorus. It’s a song to make you pause a while and reflect. Very, very nice indeed.
Monkey See, Monkey Do - Tim & Julie Warner I absolutely love this. Tim continues to morph into Tom Waits. So quirky. I sometimes wish I could see the world through Tim’s eyes (or Julie’s depending on who came up with these lyrics). The electric piano and organ is simple and effective and helps to add to the off-the-wall attitude. What really sells it all is Tim’s vocal delivery - it’s all done with complete conviction. Love the first instance of ‘Monkey See, Monkey Do’ with that little falsetto rise on ‘do’. The distorted ‘bullhorn’(?) effect is very fitting. Even though I see you had a problem with the interface and had to be a little more creative in getting the guitar done, it didn’t detract at all. Can I connect to a Valentine theme? It’s a tough call but I’m glad it’s on here nonetheless. Fabulous!
Voting is tough this month!!
|
|
|
Post by stephen on Feb 6, 2015 16:53:06 GMT
Many thanks to Rob for letting me post a second version of my song (even though all you can hear now is the bloody cymbal). There are some wonderfully recorded songs this month that make me realize I'll only ever produce demos. It's not for want of trying, though. I don't know how you do it.
Under Your Spell Robbie Good Classic John Mayall blues with some very tasty keyboards and a nice late-night club feel. I must admit I cheated and read Eddie's comment and I agree – the "under your spell" would have made a great hook. I like the verses, though, and the shock at the end. It starts out all romantic and then gives love a kick in the teeth. The blues can be cruel.
Valentine's Colin Parish You're such an old softie. Quit the dating websites? That's like saying stop drinking lattes. But it's a very effective lament for old-school courtship, with the echoey acoustic and the strings matching the theme perfectly. Great use of Garageband to produce something that sounds like a real record (remember those?).
Put It There Son Colin Parish We all need to tell our sons where to put it. (Rimshot, please). Another oldies' song – you're already thinking of becoming a granddad? I prefer this one of your two love songs, even if it does start out on a stridently anti-Valentine note. Nice hook, nice chord sequence, and again the tender mood in the instrumentation and the melody line really match the theme.
It Won't Be Long Mike Gosling Ah, a real Valentine's song. And great use of the new instrument and those five chords – who needs more? I like the idea of love melting the frost, and the folky feeling of love being linked to the seasons. You've managed to conjure up the warm feeling of a Christmas card combined with a Valentine. Hummable melody, and some economic drumming that fits really well with the whole feel of the song.
Valentine Moon Colin Steward Great twisting melody line over the solo piano, before the strings kick in and we're off into a classic dance scene from a musical. Very nice switch when the trumpet solo starts, and very accomplished outro so we end on the title of the song. The lyrics feel as though they're straight out of the 40s (which is a compliment) and the "Valentine Moon" is an excellent concept.
Moveable Feast Eddie Custard Great intro and outro, instantly memorable sing-along hook, brilliant overall sound. It feels like an Elvis Costello song – the opposite of his "I don't want to go to Chelsea" – I really want to go to Clarendon Cross. Very nice use of simple instrumentation with extras that stand out – the fuzz guitar, the a cappella section, clever use of harmonies - all backed by the powerful drum beat that matches the urgency of the lyrics. You really drum the hook into our brains.
Don't Forget My Valentine Patrick Duffin A cool mix of the 40s 50s 60s and some much more modern irony. You should start a riot if your Valentine's card doesn't arrive on time. (Though it sounds more like something someone once said to you, right?) Great period sound, a mix of "Blue Suede Shoes" and a pre-Elvis feel, and I especially like the be-bop vocals on the later choruses, a kind of Chattanooga Choo-Choo sound, if that's how you spell it. An excellent updating of a classic be-bop genre.
Love on the Doorstep Tim & Julie Warner Very funky bass riff and cool electric piano, very 70s. I like the way the dirty funk guitar of the intro melds into the smoother verses, then back again into some nicely fuzzy guitar. Reminds me of the Isley Brothers' "Who's That Lady". It's way too short, though – you could have gone beyond the doorstep, I mean, repeated it all to make a full-length song, and it would have been rewarding rather than repetitive.
As Long As I live Phil Sanderson Great "floaty" melody with its minor-key swoops – I can imagine it being sung very ethereally by a female folkie, especially the "so long will I call your name" line that feels even more melancholic than the rest. Nice guitar-picking, though I have to admit I was kind of hoping some distorted 12-string was about to appear. It's a bit like David Gilmour – poor bloke has to produce a searing solo in every song.
Valentine Tim & Glyn Beautifully naked opening (sorry that sounds a bit rude, but it is Valentine's month), and the sparse recording works really well, gradually building up – drums, harmonies, a bit of electric guitar, then overlaid vocals. I like the way the song glides along in such a laid-back groove - there's a sort of calm contentment about it. This makes it one of the most truly Valentiney songs here.
Monkey See Monkey Do Tim & Julie Warner Well we know who's been smoking the monkey droppings. This is great - I don't think there are, or will ever be, many drugged-up jams on the theme of monkey love. It's a pretty bad trip if you listen closely to the words, but that loose guitar solo is great fun, so the listener emerges more or less sane. Not sure it's a love song, but not sure it matters because that "monkey see money do" hook is inspired.
|
|
|
Post by colinallcars on Feb 7, 2015 22:13:14 GMT
So many great songs this month critiquing them is getting harder. So many of them would slot effortlessly into the playlist for a number of radio stations. Very high quality and as I said before, a new, free album every month!
Robbie Good Band Under Your Spell Great drum intro and soulful Hammond organ. Love the drums throughout. Sounds live, like it should be heard in a smokey basement. Santana-esqey guitar solo - much too short for my liking - give us more! The song ended too soon - I wanted to hear a middle eight or a chorus with a big hook (I know, coming from me that’s a bit rich!).
Mike gosling It Won’t Be Long As a ukuleleist I love the beautiful sound you have out of yours - is it a tenor? Great vocal - you have a really warm voice. The accordion gives a nice bounding bouncy feel to the song, made me want to dance. Love the harmonies, especially the Aahhs. Reminded me of Neil Innes. great job!
Colin Steward Valentine Moon Starts like a song from a musical, setting the scene before launching into that wonderful tune - the series of questions works so well and then it’s all Fred and Ginger and just perfect from 1.04 onwards. It could come straight out of a 1940s Hollywood musical. Really brilliant.
Eddie Custard Our Love is a Moveable Feast From the off this song has great harmonies and super playing - reminded me of Tears for Fears. Lovely lyrics telling me of some interesting places I’ve never heard of. Your songs always have such an energy. Not sure about the harmonies on the last bit of the acapella section but the first bit is delightful.
Patrick Duffin (Don’t Forget My) Valentine More bouncy blues - love the accordion. A jovial song with a subtle threat. Lovely singing as usual, with spot-on harmonies and diction, and I love the slide guitar - maybe this is a country song…..
Julie and Tim Warner Love on the Doorstep Funky intro with really nice interplay between the guitar, bass and drums. And then the drums come in with a great surprising beat. Super vocals from both of you, I think the ‘then perhaps some dancing’ line is very suggestive. My only criticism is this song is two minutes too short - I wanted more. You are definitely channeling Santana this month.
Stephen Clarke I Got a Crush On You Sounds like a happy song but I love the sentiment - haven’t we all ‘wasted the hours dreaming of you’ at some point of our lives? Sounds like a live recording of a band from 1978 - loving the energy. Great rhymes throughout - neurosis with roses is inspired. Lovely guitar solo. The idea of dreaming all year long about sending a Valentine card - crushing indeed!
Phil Sanderson As Long As I Live This song has a very dreamy romantic feel. The ‘so long will I call you name’ refrain is beautiful. Your voice sounds very sweet and warm - heartfelt. I like the Frenchified accordion (a popular instrument this month!) and the strings come in lushly to underline the romanticism. Lovely.
Tim and Julie Warner Monkey See, Monkey Do Quirky from the first beat to the last - love the bullhorn vocal and the way the almost comical arrangement subverts the terrible message - I remember this monkey experiment from the pages of my introductory psychology book from many moons ago. Great guitar work throughout and it’s so unusual for a song to be so thought provoking that it makes you go on to Wikipedia!!
|
|
Karl
Junior Member
Posts: 72
|
Post by Karl on Feb 8, 2015 14:00:10 GMT
Robbie Good - Under Your Spell Welcome back Robbie! It's always good to hear the live band sound, with real drums, on your entries. You do this smokey-club blues very well. I like the unusual placement of the solo and, like some others, would have liked to hear a definite chorus.
Colin Parish - Valentine's Quite a mournful feel for this song, which seems a bit at odds with the lyrics. I like the instrument choices, especially the piano part, although I would have liked to hear some real drums . The vocals get a bit lost at times - just mix them louder I guess?
Colin Parish - Put It There My Son If my comments on "Valentine's" are a bit negative, it's probably because I like this song so much more. The instrumentation is lovely - I really like your string parts and the unusual guitar parts in the intro and outro are great. The programmed rhythm is less bothersome here, and the sentiment of the lyrics is inspiring. Nice.
Colin Steward - Valentine Moon I think everyone else has said what I would have. My Mum and wife love to watch the kind of Sunday afternoon films that this song could so easily have come from. And, whilst this is not really my "cup of tea", there is so much to admire here - the playing, the arrangement, the instrumentation, Robbie's voice, I could go on... Well done.
Eddie Custard - Our Love Is A Moveable Feast This is possibly my favourite Custard song to date. I like the driving rhythm, the pounding bass line, lyrics that I can hear and get, plus guitar and key parts that fit together so well. A good feel song that draws only 1 minor criticism from me - the fade out (sorry).
Patrick Duffin - (Don't Forget My) Valentine This sounds like the kind of song that Patrick can knock out at the drop of a hat. That's not a criticism, but an observation of how easy and "right" it all sounds. As ever, really easy to listen to, and with a chorus that I was singing along to by the end of the first listen.
Tim & Julie - Love On The Doorstep I thought Tim's entry would be really cynical this month, but even though this inventive and funky tune is a bit short and possibly needs a chorus, I think it has one of the most honest and romantic ideas behind it. I also think the "perhaps some dancing" line is delivered in a very seductive manor by that minx, Julie!
Stephen Clarke - I Got A Crush On You The demo-like quality to this recording doesn't detract from what seems to me, to be a really complete song from Steven. I like it and would love to hear it worked up with full production.
Phil Sanderson - As Long As I Live Thoughtful, subtle, restrained and accomplished playing. Another "complete" song and less than 3 minutes!
Tim & Glyn - Valentine Glyns voice is lovely, and whilst I knew this, it sounds sublime on this lovely song. Keeping the programmed drums and bass line simple and was the right decision - it leaves plenty of space for the vocals and Tim's guitar playing, especially the bright lead riff which is just excellent. Well done on keeping the strings subtle too. I would have been even happier listening to this if there had been an extra chorus at the end.
Tim & Julie - Monkey See, Monkey Do Try listening to this and not smiling. Go on, try it! See what I mean - it's impossible! Fantastic stuff. I love it, even if it has little or nothing to do with Valentine's.
Now for an even harder voting decision than usual.
|
|
tandg
Junior Member
Posts: 67
|
Post by tandg on Feb 8, 2015 17:18:20 GMT
Robbie Good Band – I’m Under Your Spell Great playing by all – very clear recording, with all elements well mixed. Great vocal delivery and really enjoyed the organ part in particular. Really liked the bluesy feel of the song – like the others, I would have really liked the “I’m under you spell” to make a re-appearance as part of a chorus.
Colin Parish – Valentine’s I love the flow of the chord changes in this song and the restrained playing – strings that were welcome when they first arrived but replaced the guitar part, rather than augmenting it. It made it really interesting to listen to. I’d have liked the vocal a bit further forward in the mix but still thoroughly enjoyed the melancholy of it all.
Colin Parish – Put It There My Son You have developed a really distinctive overall sound, so that this is at once very different from ‘Valentine’s’ while still being identifiably a CP song. I thought this was obviously a happier song than Valentine’s but was actually a really moving tribute to fatherhood and certainly not mawkish. Whether or not James plays it to his friends might be a different matter!
Mike Gosling – It won’t be Long You’ve got a habit of doing this. I wasn’t sure about this for the first minute – for me it didn’t have a natural flow to it until the aah-aah’s came in and the snare joined in. From then on, it was thoroughly enjoyable, with a really enjoyable sort of Cajun feel to it. The accordion sound was great and I immediately played it again (and this time enjoyed the first minute as well).
Colin Steward – Valentine Moon Amazing stuff! You’ve commented on your musical influences in your song comments over the past few months but you didn’t mentioned classic musicals. The arrangement is so well thought out - the high strings and wonderful piano playing make this completely absorbing. The brushed drums and the cornet/muted trumpet solo are just lovely and the twisting melody line and key changes make for a surprisingly complex composition. Robbie’s voice and delivery deserves special mention and great lyrics – I particularly liked the comparison with other holidays/celebrations (“birthday’s make you old..” is a great thought). Not my style of music and yet my favourite song this month – it shows the benefit of the collective...it makes you listen with a different mindset.
Eddie Custard – Our Love is a Moveable Feast This is the most celebratory mood of all the songs this month and that really sets it apart. A real celebration of a relationship and the places associated with it. This cries out for a video – the descriptions are so finely wrought it sounds like a joyous travelogue as well as a love song. I’m beginning to take for granted that I’ll love the sound of your songs, the great arrangements and killer key changes and this is no exception.
Patrick Duffin – (Don’t Forget My) Valentine Wonderfully witty lyrics and effortless sounding production make this a pleasure to listen to. I particularly like the paradox “Take as long as you like but I want my card on time”. I loved the slide guitar playing and the beautifully restrained harmonies. As always, your production is a lesson to us all and the performance is so ‘right’ with everything fitting perfectly in its own ‘space’.
Tim & Julie – Love on the Doorstep Great groove – it sounds loose and tight all at once, which I love. The most unpredictable song here and the most unconventional. I liked that it was short but desperately wanted it to carry on. I thought the very brief descriptions of a first date left so much unsaid (which is wonderful as it leaves so much to our imaginations) and yet I wanted to know more about it. Knowing how long you’ve been together, perhaps it’s asking too much for more than 1 minute 38 seconds of shared memories! Great guitar playing on here and good crisp recording (in spite of the problems you indicated).
Stephen Clarke – I Got a Crush on You Roses rhyme with neuroses! Brilliant. This channels a cross between Buzzcocks and Jilted John beautifully, with witty lyrics and a great groove. I liked the harmonies in the chorus and playing in the solo – particularly as it seemed that there wasn’t going to be one – just a change of chords instead. I liked the vocal sound and the simple arrangement and clear production. Most of all the chorus is catchy – a hit!
Phil Sanderson – As Long as I Live At first I thought it sounded a little too earnest but by the end I just thought it sounds really honest. Lovely sounds –the classical guitar and the accordion in particular are really nicely put together. I really enjoyed the laid back groove – the song feels almost like a monologue / stream of consciousness and yet there’s just enough variation to maintain interest and the line ‘so long will I call your name’ really makes the song for me. Lovely.
Tim & Julie – Monkey See, Monkey Do Love the vocal sound – a slightly uncomfortable song to listen to and all the better for that. Yet again, you’ve shown a wonderfully experimental approach and no particular desire to follow a formula – the song is structured enough without being constrained and could easily have gone anywhere but for the electronic sequence tumbling along throughout the song. I loved the interplay between that and the guitar. Congratulations on the Robert Fripp style playing – it fits brilliantly with the unsettling lyrics and the uneasy atmosphere you created. Terrific stuff.
|
|
|
Post by philsanderson on Feb 12, 2015 22:40:48 GMT
Sorry I’m somewhat late with comments and voting. Could offer lame excuses..eg ‘it’s the last week of a seemingly endless half term and I’m knackered’ or ‘I ran a long race at the weekend and it’s taken its toll on mind and body’ .... or .... I’ll try not to repeat what others have said this month, but there’s bound to be some doubling up of opinions / ideas !
Under Your Spell - Robbie Good Band Excellent clear sound throughout song, and powerful vocal lines, delivered flawlessly. Unlike some other reviewers I don’t miss the lack of a definite chorus. This may more reflect my frequent lack of respect for more orthodox song structures!
Valentine’s - Colin Parish Another very English sounding song from Colin! Great arrangement and choice of instrumentation. I can relate to the messages in the lyrics completely! Has a sort of sad feel about it, which I can also relate to ( see my rather frequent melancholic lyrical efforts ) I like the way you used the panning on the guitars, strings in mix. I missed this on first two listenings through speakers, and only picked up on this through headphones.
Put it There My Son - Colin Parish I like the introduction of distorted guitar, I would like to have heard a bit more even! A very personal song, Colin. I couldn’t bring myself to broadcast what I had originally written for this month which was in a vaguely similar vein to this ( although rather more downbeat again! ). You’ve pulled it off expertly, and I definitely would not have been able to do this. Well done, a great effort.
It Won’t Be Long - Mike Gosling A lovely upbeat song. Much better accordion sound and playing than my brief attempt! I picked up on first listening on the excellent backing vocal as well as terrific lead. Great drumming, too! The production on this is second to none - as always your entries give me something to aspire to ( although I may give trying a ukulele a miss for the time being until I get a lot more competent – I’ve had a first go on a borrowed one, and I was severely rubbish! )
Valentine Moon – Colin Steward I love all this song, but am particularly fond of opening minute or so. It’s great to listen to the piano playing on this. I’m frequently wondering why I don’t use piano more in the SWC as it’s my main instrument, but hearing Colin in full flow makes me reflect on my own limitations, and I may stick to guitars for a while whilst I try to improve my keyboard skills. The song conjures up all sorts of warm images – some of them in black and white!
Our Love is a Moveable Feast - Eddie Custard The chords, vocal and melody seem so natural again. There are definite echoes / homages ( maybe to Neil Finn ) contained in this song. As usual the lyrics are brilliant from first word to last. I’m envious of anyone who can write lyrics sounding so good on a regular basis. ( In fact I’m a little envious of anyone who can write lyrics at all - usually I can only seem to manage to write words which 11 year olds and under can sing without sounding crass). This song really sticks in my head after each listening. A definite winner!
(Don’t Forget My) Valentine - Patrick Duffin Another slice of brilliance! Every note and beat on this seems perfect. There’s a lot going on behind the vocals, but it’s all superbly executed. Each time I hear this on headphones I sort of follow a different instrument’s path through the song. When I hear a PD song I wonder now hat the starting point was... a melody, hook line, chord progression.........whatever it is – it works each time!
Love on the Doorstep - Tim & Julie Warner .....you leave us wanting more here! I got the same Jamiroquai experience as Colin S when I heard this. I like the more upbeat feel of this song. The drumbeats and bass lines you are using really work for you, especially on this... why did it have to end so early? Maybe a remix will be forthcoming??
I Got a Crush on You - Stephen Clarke Another stroke of brilliant ‘retro’ lyric writing and delivery! My comments on this will completely echo what others have said in praise! I’m taken back to late 70s, and can imagine a great video to go with this. Didn’t hear the version without the extra drums. I can, however, imagine it was absolutely fine without!
Valentine - Tim & Glyn Very moving, very haunting, very wonderful, very ( add impressive adjective here!!) Great guitar sounds, perfectly considered and balanced. Vocal delivery from Glyn is surreally good ( can you say that ?) – I found myself drawn to playing this song first on the last two occasions when I opened up the Jan Songs page to review them.
Monkey See, Monkey Do - Tim & Julie Warner Is it still Valentine’s month? Who cares? It’s love found in the sound of a new song –ahhh! I especially like the electric piano sound you have discovered – it goes so well with your guitar parts. On a random dog walk in the near future I’ll be tackling you on this so I can get it too ( don’t have an ipad / garageband etc etc, though so might be investing soon )
Voting will be almost impossible, but will give it a go - maybe even change vote by tomorrow, as I cannot seem to agree with my own opinion from one day to the next ! Only one more day at school, .....and then my mind will probably automatically clear and I'll know for definite who to vote for!
|
|
|
Post by colinallcars on Feb 15, 2015 21:18:50 GMT
Two worthy winners - well done guys.
|
|
|
Post by Patrick on Feb 16, 2015 11:01:58 GMT
Indeed! Well done Colin and Eddie
|
|
|
Post by Colin Steward on Feb 16, 2015 20:09:23 GMT
Some lovely comments, thanks everyone. Fist bump to Eddie. Onwards and upwards!
|
|
|
Post by mikegosling on Feb 16, 2015 21:54:08 GMT
Congrats to Colin (and Robbie) and to Eddie - both great songs.
|
|
|
Post by eddiecustard on Feb 17, 2015 2:06:43 GMT
Thanks for the kind comments. Well done, Colin - your song's a beauty.
|
|
Karl
Junior Member
Posts: 72
|
Post by Karl on Feb 17, 2015 6:09:14 GMT
Well done Colin. Well done Eddie. Worthy winners.
|
|
|
Post by stephen on Feb 17, 2015 15:52:25 GMT
Well done Colin and Eddie. Though if you form a duo, I think it should be Steward & Custard.
|
|
|
Post by Colin Steward on Feb 17, 2015 16:07:08 GMT
I'd be tempted to change my name to Rhubarb of course. But if Eddie would prefer top billing and feels his name should be first, I'd change mine to Tart!
|
|
tandg
Junior Member
Posts: 67
|
Post by tandg on Feb 17, 2015 19:46:01 GMT
Two really good songs and worthy winners. Please don't form a duo because we want to hear 2 songs each month (although Colin Custard has a certain something)!
|
|
|
Post by eddiecustard on Feb 18, 2015 16:17:08 GMT
Let's go for Stewed Custard.
|
|
|
Post by Colin Steward on Feb 18, 2015 17:15:58 GMT
Sounds like a good name for a prog rock band. I'm in!
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Feb 19, 2015 12:08:36 GMT
Hats off to Stewart Custard
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on Feb 19, 2015 18:28:03 GMT
January/February 2015 Song Reviews
Review. A bit late but I DID vote.
I changed my approach this month by downloading all the songs and having them with me virtually all the time (in the car, on a run etc) allowing them to seep into my subconscious (at least, that was the theory.) As ever, I wished we’d had more votes but those are the rules!
The Robbie Good Band I’m under your spell
The recording is fantastically clear and well defined. I have seen the RG band live and my admiration increases every time I see them. This is a very assured and believable performance. After the first listening I wasn’t so fussed on the vocal-line (the melody) but it is definitely an ‘ear-worm’ and when it came to sitting down and writing a review, I was singing the lines before the song began. The structure is a little odd but I quite like it, particularly at the end when Robbie appears to rejoin part way through an instrumental verse and then finishes the whole thing solo. I think this is one of the best RG Band songs thus far.
Addendum. This melody really IS an ear worm. So much so that I really want it out of my head now please!
Colin Parish Valentine’s
Colin gets better and better with every month. This is a very commanding performance and there are some lovely moments and some quite ‘dark’ chord changes. And this is where I had a slight problem and wondered whether the premise of ‘lonely people’ sitting on their computers in the bedrooms should have been expanded in a darker way given the mood the chords and melody generated. As with Robbie’s song, I was singing the melody before the song started (after a few listens) which is the sign of a memorable melody.
Colin Parish Put it there my son (Genes and instinct)
Melodically, this is not as good as the previous one. Musically, this is as simple as it gets and reminded me a bit of ‘That’s Entertainment’ by ‘The Jam’ (a song I really don’t like!) HOWEVER, the lyrics really, really resonated for me. It was heart-on-the-sleeve stuff. You just laid it out there and I really admire that. Consequently, (and bizarrely) this is my favourite song of yours thus far even though you’ve produced better music previously, in my opinion. Well done.
Mike Gosling It Won’t Be Long
A valentine’s waltz. Once again, Mike produces a song that’s easy on the ear both musically and sonically. His ‘vocal chorus-line’ is becoming increasingly sophisticated. I can imagine this in any scenario. It could have had Christmas lyrics added to it. It could have been a track in the middle of an animated film or it could be played at the local folk club. Having said all that, I wasn’t as engaged as perhaps I should have been and I’m not sure why. It ticks so many boxes and yet doesn’t tick the ‘X Factor’ box (I don’t mean that it should have had whiter teeth and a key change!) it just didn’t catch fire but one can’t argue with all the good things in it, particularly the clarity of the recording and the top-drawer Ukulele playing!
Colin Steward Valentine Moon
This transported me back to what I’d imagine a smoky cocktail bar would have felt like in the 40s and 50s. Having said that, I really took against the strings when they arrived with the drums! (I think the sound reminded me too much of the duo who used to play on the MV St Nicholas between Harwich and the Hook of Holland!) That said, I loved some of the lyrical references and the melody was strong. Not my favourite Colin Steward song but very accomplished (and welcome back!)
Eddie Custard Moveable Feast
This is out of the blocks like a rocket. Eddie delivers on every front with this. Fantastic melody, brilliant arrangement (great middle 8) and just an amazing and enjoyable experience. (However, dare I say that Eddie loses his way slightly with the vocal section after the instrumental? - thank god he’s human!) When the writing is this good, it’s easy to get picky with the minutiae of the critique so I’m not going to as this is just great. I’m a big fan.
Patrick Duffin Don’t Forget My Valentine
And just when you think you’ve probably heard the best song of the collection, this comes along! Not only is it a great idea with great, ironic humour but it is sonically superior than everything else thus far and the musicianship is absolutely top drawer. I know it’s very derivative (a blues trip), but who cares? Brilliant.
Tim & Julie Warner Love on the doorstep
I suspect that Tim has taken delivery of new drum and bass loops! I really like this. Very unusual and increasingly assured. Though I have to say I felt like a bit of a gooseberry (and having seen over the years how you two operate, I would definitely have felt like a gooseberry had I been there!) I don’t know if it was deliberately this short, but I think that was very clever; a verse each, instrumental and then out! Phew, breathtaking.
Stephen Clarke I’ve Got a Crush On You
I’m going to have to say it; this is my favourite song of the month. Stephen has humour by the ton but his songs also have great melody and simple charm. There is nothing spare in this song. It’s simply brilliant and the song I would have wanted to have written (if I’d contributed this month!) Well done, Stephen.
Phil Sanderson As Long as I live
Flushed from the success of the previous month, Phil appears to have new found confidence and this is a very much calmer and less frenetic Phil S composition. The vocal is the best I’ve heard from him. I like the line ‘…whilst I still have feet to drag’ and I really like the extremely subtle way he introduced a string pad into the second verse and I really like the instrumental (the change of key/chords really works) but the curse of poor-timing strikes toward the end of this section. Overall, I really like this.
Tim & Glyn Valentine
I know Tim & Glyn and I’ve known them for a long time so, after listening to the song a number of times I stopped listening to the vocal sound (gorgeous), melody and instrumentation and started to listen to the lyrics. It seemed a very personal statement and there were some beautiful lines (I particularly liked the ‘don’t need a husband, you don’t need a wife. Please be my valentine.’) I thought this was really easy on the earned reminded me of some of those John Martyn songs that Tim & Glyn used to play to me. Constructively, I think sometimes you could be a little braver with the mixing because though one can hear everything, perhaps it would be better to hear some things over others. Overall, I really, really liked this.
Tim & Julie Warner Monkey See, Monkey Do
After a few listens, I think it became clear that Tim & Julie had been heavily influenced in the production of this by Tony Visconti’s production of David Bowie’s ‘Scary Monsters’ even to the point of the edgy/wrong key guitar toward the end. But I really liked this and it once again shows the amazing distance that Tim and Julie have travelled with their songwriting these past months. Confidence now exudes every utterence and every note. The best of their two entries - I wonder which one would have made the cut if the ‘one-song-per-songwriter’ rule had come into effect this month?
|
|