|
Post by Rob W on Sept 8, 2014 17:41:52 GMT
Hi All
I am in the eye of the storm at the moment!! We are in the process of moving home and tomorrow I pack up my editing computer in readiness for the move (timeframe in-exact at the moment.)
What I'm trying to say is that October's 'write a theme tune using a supplied video' task will need to happen in the new year. So my suggestion would be that we use one of the ideas that has already been mooted and that is...
...a limited instrument month.
This will hopefully help those who have a less sophisticated set up. So the rules (which are open for discussion) would be
a) A maximum of five instruments (including a vocal) can be used.
b) The instruments cannot be multi-layered. If a guitar plays a solo, it doesn't play backing chords. If a guitar has a riff, it has to be able to be played in one take, ie no harmonies. The same applies to keyboards; choose one sound and stick with it (unless you're forfeiting for eg a guitar in which case you can use two keyboard sounds and if guitarists are forfeiting a keyboard, you can use two guitars.) Vocals are solo, no harmonies (unless you're making ALL the instruments vocals.)
I suppose the spirit of what I'm saying is that you have to imagine sitting in a rehearsal room and being able to play your song with four other musicians.
I'll put this onto the forum but I wanted to make sure you all got the message in case you're not checking that part of the forum.
Regards
Rob
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on Sept 8, 2014 18:00:21 GMT
Just to clarify, drums are one instrument. Extra percussion is another instrument. You have to imagine yourself sitting down and being able to play the drums in one take (in other words, you couldn't play a drum kit and shake a tambourine at the same time - a 'hit' tambourine may be allowed as that could, in theory, be hit at the same time as, say, a snare etc.
I suppose my thought was that most of the bands I have been in have had drums, a guitar, a bass, a vocalist and then either a second guitar or a keyboard. Think like a band (or form a band and record your song live.)
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Sept 9, 2014 9:03:36 GMT
Sorry if this sounds stupid, but I just want to be absolutely clear. We have to imagine a voice counts as one, guitar counts one, bass etc and we can only go upto a total of five. Is that how it works?
It's just that I play in a band with four others, so we have five instruments and four voices (Colin refuses to sing but, as I've never heard him, I'm not sure why). So playing in The Spiderz we can require a bit more than 5 channels on a recording device. I'd hate to be DQ'd on a technicality.
|
|
|
Post by Colin Steward on Sept 9, 2014 9:34:36 GMT
If you heard me sing you'd understand why I refuse. It could be the 'listening to your own voice' syndrome of course but I did try out recording myself for one of the previous songs and quickly deleted it after hearing it back! Maybe one day I'll give it a go to prove my point!
Good luck with the move, Rob, hope it goes seamlessly well.
|
|
|
Post by Rob W on Sept 9, 2014 16:45:08 GMT
I'm open to ideas and opinions. The idea is that this task will (hopefully) benefit those who use a more basic recording set up and so the restriction was imposed to keep it simple. If everyone else thinks that vocals should be exempt from the rule, I have no problem with it but unless we hear other dissenting voices, let's stick with the original premise of five instruments - the voice being one instrument. Maybe you could do a barbershop quartet with a single guitar accompaniment?
|
|
|
Post by timwarner on Sept 9, 2014 17:51:29 GMT
Thanks for the clarification. It's what I hoped it would be. It should help focus our ideas.
|
|